Mohan Bhagwat’s ‘Retire at 75’ Remark Sparks Intense Debate on PM Modi’s Future
Introduction
At a high-profile book launch in Nagpur on 5 July 2025, RSS Sarsanghchalak Mohan Bhagwat recounted a story about late ideologue Moropant Pingle. Pingle, upon turning 75, quipped that the ceremonial shawl he received was society’s gentle way of saying, “Please step aside.” Bhagwat used this anecdote to suggest that anyone who reaches age 75 should voluntarily retire from active leadership roles. The comment immediately fueled speculation about Prime Minister Narendra Modi, who shares a September 1950 birth year with Bhagwat and will also turn 75 this year.
Who Is Mohan Bhagwat?
Mohan Bhagwat became the RSS chief in March 2009, succeeding K. S. Sudarshan. As Sarsanghchalak, he has overseen significant expansion of the RSS’s social and political outreach. Under his leadership, the RSS has deepened ties with affiliated bodies, including the BJP, while also strengthening grassroots cadres across India’s states. Despite no formal term limit for the Sarsanghchalak, Bhagwat’s remark has drawn attention to the question of age and active leadership.
The Anecdote and Its Implications
Bhagwat narrated how Moropant Pingle, loyal RSS ideologue, received a shawl on his 75th birthday in the 1990s. Pingle told the gathering that a shawl at that age was effectively a polite dismissal from active duties. By highlighting this, Bhagwat implied that leadership roles carry an unspoken age threshold. Observers quickly linked this to forthcoming debates on whether the Prime Minister should step back upon turning 75.
Political Reactions
Opposition leaders seized on Bhagwat’s comments as an indirect message to Narendra Modi, whose 75th birthday falls on 17 September 2025.
- Jairam Ramesh (Congress) noted that both Bhagwat and Modi share birthdays in September and quipped that Bhagwat’s rule applied equally.
- Abhishek Singhvi (Congress) accused the RSS of preaching a rule they do not follow, pointing out that Bhagwat continues beyond 75.
- Priyanka Chaturvedi (Shiv Sena UBT) claimed the remark was aimed squarely at Modi, reflecting growing RSS–BJP friction.
- Sanjay Raut (Shiv Sena UBT) recalled Modi’s past sidelining of veterans like L.K. Advani after they passed 75 and asked whether Modi would enforce the same norm on himself.
BJP’s Official Response
The BJP quickly distanced itself from any suggestion of an age cap:
- Maharashtra BJP chief Chandrashekhar Bawankule clarified that there is no party rule on retirement at 75.
- In August 2024, Home Minister Amit Shah dismissed rumors of Modi’s impending exit, assuring that Modi would lead through 2029 if the National Democratic Alliance won again.
- BJP leaders stressed that neither their constitution nor RSS tradition enforces a mandatory retirement age for office-bearers at 75.
Historical Precedents and Age Norms
Traditionally, RSS elders above 75 transition into a Margdarshak Mandal, an advisory council, while relinquishing day-to-day duties. In the BJP, several senior leaders crossed 75 in recent years and saw reduced roles:
- L.K. Advani and Murli Manohar Joshi were moved into advisory roles after 75.
- Jaswant Singh, too, found his active involvement limited upon reaching the milestone.
Critics argue that age-based retirements have been selectively applied, questioning the consistency of such norms.
Age Comparison at a Glance
| Leader | Date of Birth | Age Today (July 2025) | Turning 75 on |
|---|---|---|---|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Political and Governance Implications
Bhagwat’s comment has broader resonance beyond personalities, raising questions about the balance between experience and renewal. A voluntary retirement at 75 could unlock leadership opportunities for younger cadres in both the RSS and BJP. Yet critics warn that forcing seasoned leaders out risks losing institutional memory and strategic depth. As the country braces for the 2029 general election, the debate over age may shape candidate selection and campaign narratives.
Looking Ahead
With both Mohan Bhagwat and Narendra Modi nearing the symbolic 75-year mark, public and political eyes will remain fixed on the two leaders. Will Bhagwat adhere to the principle he espoused and step down in September? Will Modi, buoyed by electoral victories, defy calls for age-related limits? The coming months promise heated discussions, strategic realignments, and potential shifts in how India’s most influential leaders plan their legacies.
Comments
Post a Comment